Star Fox 2: The Forgotten Flight of Fox McCloud

starfox2_title

Star Fox was a bit of an obsession in my household back in the day. My brother was something of a master — even playing competitively — and while I can’t claim I approached that level of dedication, I always had a soft spot for it.

I returned not too long ago, with the intent of finally conquering so-called “Level 3,” the most difficult route to Venom, and the one I had never been able to see through to its conclusion.

How unexpected, then, that I made it through after only a few tries. From the moment I defeated Andross’ weird metal cat-face form — that battle I’d watched so many times but never taken part in myself — I knew I wanted more. But here I was, for the first time, with no more of Star Fox left undiscovered.

Then I remembered Star Fox 2.

If you didn’t know that was a thing, don’t feel bad. It’s not exactly common knowledge. I couldn’t tell you where I first heard about it, and even though the game has existed as some vague concept in the back of my mind for ages, I never got around to checking it out until now.

See, Star Fox 2 was canned back in 1995 in favor of Star Fox 64, even though it was essentially finished. You can read more about that on Wikipedia or TV Tropes or wherever; point is — a 99% complete version of the game was leaked online, translated, and patched up.

And you can play it.

Now that I’ve played through it a few times, I think I can say without exaggeration that it may be the greatest unreleased game of all time. I’ll reserve my judgment on that one, though, in case Van Buren someday sees the light of day.

That said, it’s not quite what I was expecting, and if you go in looking for more of the same old Star Fox, you may be disappointed. Let’s jump in and I’ll try to explain.

starfox2_intro
Spoiler: It doesn’t go quite the way he plans.

Andross is back. I bet you didn’t see that one coming!

All the original members of team Star Fox also return, plus two newcomers: Miyu and Fay. This time around, instead of all pilots flying off together, you choose who you want to play as. Who you choose determines which model Arwing you’ll be piloting, and each has different attributes. Fox and Falco pilot the classic, middle-of-the-road, bomb-toting version. There’s a shield-heavy juggernaut of an Arwing, complete with deployable repair drone, which goes to Peppy and Slippy, while the new team members’ model is the opposite: small, fast, and with a nose ahead in the weapons department, since it carries the Twin Blaster right from the get-go.

If this is a hard choice for you, you’ll be comforted by the fact that you actually choose two pilots — and you can switch between them at any time from the map screen (or if one is shot down, you resume the game as the other).

starfox2_select
At the far right of the pilot select are Fay, who I think is a poodle, and Miyu… who looks like some kind of cat?

In addition to the familiar faces, you’ve got an aesthetic almost unchanged from the first game. It’s still that charming early 3D style of the Super FX chip, all solid-color polygons and low frame-rates. I’m still not sure why the engine only seems to be able to render polygons in shades of grey, blue, and orange, but at this point it’s just one of those little details that makes me smile. The game does seem to have more detailed (and really beautiful) backgrounds than the original, though. They even tried to texture a lot of the objects in the game, but that just makes the early-3D-ness of it all the more obvious; all the textured surfaces tend to have that warbly, jittering effect you see in a lot of 3D games from the mid-90s. Still, I have a soft spot for that stuff too.

The game holds to its arcade-y roots, too. Both it and the original are the type of game you can play from start to finish in under an hour. I tend to seek out the types of games that are long and involved, with worlds I can really sink my teeth into and get immersed in, but actually, the Star Fox experience is a refreshing change from that.

starfox2_map
Go anywhere! Do anything! Be anyone!

Here’s where it really starts to become obvious how different things are. This is the stage select screen, so to speak. Rather than choosing a set path at the start, like you did in Star Fox, you move freely over this map of the Lylat system, meaning you can do the “stages” in any order.

I’m guessing free movement was something of a mission statement for Star Fox 2, because the stages are opened up in a similar way. The linear stuff from the first game is completely gone. That means more exploration, and more focus generally on finding or destroying things rather than surviving a finely crafted obstacle course. You might lament the change, but just go with it for now. I promise it’s still awesome, just in a different way.

The stages basically fall into two categories: space battles and ground missions.

Andross is actively attacking Corneria this time around, so most battles you fight in space will be your attempts at intercepting missiles and fighter squadrons on their way toward the planet. There’s also the occasional dogfight with one of Andross’ minions or with members of the mercenary team Star Wolf, who he’s hired to take you down. The Star Wolf battles are especially exciting, since their ships are effectively the mirror versions of your own, complete with nasty charge-blasts and barrel rolls to deflect your attacks.

starfox2_pigma
Didn’t I already blow you up in Star Fox 64?

The other type of mission, the ground stages, involve infiltrating an enemy base in order to destroy it and remove a missile battery from the battlefield. You have to activate a number of switches to access the base and then fight your way through a series of corridors and rooms inside. That probably sounds a little difficult for an Arwing, but here’s the thing: in Star Fox 2, the Arwings can morph into a walker form at any time during a ground mission. With the walker, you’ve got way more control over your movement.

It’s also just a ton of fun being able to switch between a sleek space ship and a walking weapons platform with the press of a button.

starfox2_walker

Another type of mission, the ones where you assault one of Andross’ battleships, combines the two types above, with a short space sequence at the beginning and an interior section just like insides of the planetary bases.

While all this is going on, the game keeps chugging along. Even while you’re down on a planet or held up by Star Wolf, everything on the map keeps moving in real-time, and you’ll be updated by General Pepper about missile launches and any other important changes on the battlefield. Star Wolf mercs can even join in on a stage already in progress. While you’re busy trying to shoot down a bunch of missiles, members of Star Wolf might drop in if they’re close enough and make things even more chaotic. (And the missiles can get away from you in the scuffle!)

Considering the insane ambition of the game, it’s pretty incredible how tight the design is. It all comes down to managing your time and keeping track of multiple threats at once. Speed is the name of the game. You might at first think it’s weird that some encounters are over in seconds, or complain about it being so easy to destroy the reactors at the end of the ground missions, but that’s the point. They’re not bosses. They’re just one kind of objective, and the whole point is that you have to complete these things as fast as possible to get back out there and defend Corneria.

starfox2_clear
These aren’t seconds, and they certainly aren’t minutes, so… We’ll just call them Time Units, I guess?

Every second you spend on one mission means you’re not spending that time somewhere else doing some other thing just as vital to the survival of Corneria. It’s all about prioritizing and knowing whether you can take out this base and still get back in time to stop that missile.

Not only is it stupid amounts of fun, since the battle plays out differently each time, there’s a surprising amount of replay value. Not to mention that you’ll find some new thing to love on each run.

The developers packed this game with plenty of brilliant little details, just as icing on the cake. Like how the backgrounds in the space battles change depending on where you are on the map screen, with different colors of nebulae or, if you’re near a planet, that planet hanging out in the distance. How about all the different types of switches, all activated in different ways — most of which are only used once in the game? And then there’s that water planet where you transform into the walker and sink to the ocean floor, complete with (amazingly goofy) swimming animation!

I could go on and on about the little touches that make this game. It’s clear that somebody cared about the product they were making, and it’s a shame it was never officially released. There was love put into this game, and that love comes through in playing it.

So — give it a shot. Just don’t get discouraged by a playthrough on the the Normal difficulty. The Expert setting is really the only challenging one, but the lower levels are good to get yourself acquainted with the way the game works.

Of course, now that I’ve played Star Fox 2, I’ll always long for a Star Fox 3. 64 just wasn’t the same. It feels like something was lost in the translation, and some magic and specialness vanished along the way. Maybe it’s the jump to a less abstract art style on the N64, or the loss of the wildly unique, slick soundtrack. Maybe it’s just that I’m frustrated that Nintendo chose to reboot and overwrite a game they’d made just four years prior.

Whatever my hangup is, I think Star Fox 2 will remain the final flight of Fox McCloud for me.

Well, it ain’t a bad note to go out on.

starfox2_success
See you, space cowboy.

5 comments

    1. It’s a little unpolished, especially compared to the first game, likely because that last 1% would have been polish, but I also think the 360 degree freedom just forces things to be a tad clunkier by its very nature. Like… you can often see objects through walls or other objects. There are some big framerate issues, too. And then there’s that texture issue I mentioned.

      Still, I’d agree with you about it being gorgeous. You could always pass it off as nostalgia goggles (for the Star Fox experience in general, not Star Fox 2 specifically), but I really do think the game is lovely.

  1. Glad to see that I’m not the only one who feels that SF64 lost something. I also just don’t enjoy the retconned version of Lylat. The SF1 Lylat was very exciting, intimidating, and unique. The SF64 Lylat is just boring by comparison, and of course SF64’s soundtrack doesn’t hold a candle to the SNES one.

    Regarding Star Fox 2, I think what I like most about it is that it is so ambitious. I agree that it isn’t as polished as the first one, but I also suspect that, yes, there was still some polishing to be done before actual release. I remember being a bit let down with the lack of on-rails levels and the bases’ cores not really being fights, but you make a great point about how you need to blow through them as fast as possible. One other thing that bothered me that I saw you mention, too, is how the primary challenge only really comes through defending Corneria and not through potentially dying. The Corneria defense mechanic is definitely the heart of the game, and I really like it, but I would like to have seen more challenging battles that could really throw you for a loop. I also thought there are too many energy pick-ups, even on Expert mode.

    That aside, the Arwing walkers are all too cool. 🙂

    I could go on and on about this game and Star Fox in general, but I’ll stop. I’m glad you really enjoyed this game as much as I do. I, too, will always pine for a Star Fox 3. 🙁

    1. I’m a little biased toward disliking Star Fox 64 just because reboots/remakes bug me. Throwing out all the work and story to retread ground we’ve already been over. I’ll never get it. But even if I didn’t dislike it for being a remake and for being the reason Star Fox 2 was canned, it still fails on the music front. You’re right; Star Fox WAS that soundtrack.

      I totally agree with you on all your comments about SF2, too. In its defense, though, I actually did lose one of my pilots on my first successful run of Expert! (Falco, I think. And I’d lost Slippy on Venom when I beat Level 3 in the first game. So in my canon, only half of the original Star Fox team is left alive. Oops!) But once you know what you’re doing, even Expert stops being a challenge, sadly.

      We may never have a Star Fox 3, but at least we got two, and they’re two of the most replayable games out there. Ah well. The good ones die young…

      1. Yeah, the whole thing with the retcon is that the version of Lylat in SF64 and onward just isn’t as interesting as the SNES Lylat. It’s just a pretty lame place. The locales aren’t as rich, the universe isn’t as dangerous. And the interesting stuff that you found out through the quick briefings and the manual of the SNES one was pretty neat, whereas I didn’t really find that stuff very interesting in SF64.

        Ultimately, I think one of the biggest crimes SF2’s cancellation resulted in was that the lore in the manual was never released. And that’s just a crying shame.

        In my mind, SF64 and beyond are the bored dreams of James McCloud as he drifts in a coma in the Awesome Black Hole. Hahaha.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *